Alma Payne
May 25, 2021
The
Language Experiment
I
did this activity with my boyfriend in the kitchen and we were talking about my
son’s soccer practice. He asked me how was his first practice today, I found
the conversation to be awkward because I did not say anything (verbally) but
still being able to use my head, hands, and expressions, he was able to grasp
my responses, It sort of felt like charades. He id not alter the way he asked
his questions but he felt it was weird that it was a one-sided conversation because
I was unable to ask question back or give open ended comments which gives him
the room carry on the conversation easier. My boyfriend was in control of the
conversation, He initiated the topic by asking about how my son’s day was at soccer
practice? He definitely had the hand up in the conversation because I was
unable to answer back. When it comes to this particular conversation where you
can only use non verbal ques, it is a language that everyone world wide will be
able to understand. The only thing that would make it culturally a problem if
different hand gestures mean something else in different cultures. Like the
looking at your watch gesture, means “im in a hurry” or I got to be somewhere”,
in the United States, but in the middle east, in a conversation should not run
on time, and it would be rude to look at your watch- mid-conversation. SO just
depending on who you are talking to it can be taking in different ways.
According to concordian.org, “Western cultures, especially that of native
English-speakers, tend to view silence as problematic. Worse still, in a
Western social context silence is often perceived as a sign of inattention,
apathy or even hostility.” (https://www.concordian.net/post/the-sounds-of-silence).
According to the famous Chinese philosopher Lao Tzu, "Silence is a source
of great strength". In China, silence is often used to indicate agreement
and receptiveness. In Asian cultures silence can often be a sign of respect. If
an Asian person asks a question, it is considered polite for the listener to
pause to consider the answer – even if they know the answer immediately. By not
being able to use any gestures it was almost impossible to have a conversation
and it actually comes off as rude because the person has no idea what was
happen and felt he was being ignored. This assignment was difficult because you
can talk to the person., if you cant use and gestures it makes thinks almost
impossible to complete a conversation. This assignment has shown me just how
important t is to have sign language as a form of communication for those who don’t
have the ability to speak verbally. It brings to light how powerful body
language, the way we stand the expression on our face can speak volume to us
and means just as much as what actually comes out of mouth, but the energy that
we put off. In fact, according to tutorialpoints.com, “Our body language helps
others identify our emotions, status and even our lifestyle. Non-verbal
communication plays a significant role in conjunction with the spoken words.
... Any sign of conflict between the body language and our words can make us
appear untrustworthy and deceptive.
Being able to read and understand
body language , gives us a better understanding as to the person we are having
a conversation with. Body language is more that just something we put on for an interview and it can only help you get
a job opportunity, body language is way more important than we think, and without
proper body language, in bland conversation where you are wondering how genuine
the person is or how sure they are, there are many difficulties in the absence
of body language in places like home, school or the workplace. So along with paying attention to
your body language, you should always pay attention to how people around you
use body language to express their opinions - this allows you to accurately
determine your next move. So when I think of a body language style that can be
taken “the wrong way”, I think of fidgeting, fidgeting may mean that there is a
lack of interaction between the two sides of the conversation. Many people who have anxiety will fidget and people
make take that as a sign of rudeness or being impatient, it also a defensive mechanism
and is done to self sooth. Turning to other directions rather than talking to
each other, or crossing your hands to your chest can mean that the other party
does not agree with your opinion, or that the content of the conversation gives
them a tendency to close their minds. Loich Batumba, vice president of the
student council of EHL, says that he clearly remembers similar experiences: “At
the time of my first interview, my interviewer and I barely communicated
eye-to-eye, so I could clearly feel that there is a lack of interest between
our conversations”.
Initial comment: When all your points are collapsed into one paragraph, it makes it difficult to parse out your responses to each prompt. It is to your advantage to ensure that your answers are clearly indicated. Separate each set of guideline prompts into separate paragraphs.
ReplyDeletePart 1: Good opening description. One question:
"He id not alter the way he asked his questions..."
But would he normally be asking all the questions? Or would you be asking them as well for him to respond to? Switching from a give-and-take engagement to one where one person is asking all the questions and the other is responding IS altering they way you engage with someone.
Good discussion on the issue of power and control in the conversation.
Missing a response to the question asking about communicating complex ideas?
I appreciate the discussion on the matter of "silence" in a conversation, but recognize that that silence is an issue of *choice* in the examples you cite. That doesn't match the conditions of this experiment, in which silence on your part was not by choice. The issues you raise are very interesting, but they get to cultural differences in *body language* (since that is effectively what silence is) and would actually apply to the final question of the second experiment.
To find a real life example of this experiment, we need to find a situation where you have a speaking population and another group that doesn't speak that language, and this results in a power differential, with the speaking culture having power over the non-speaking. We see that in the interaction between English speakers and non-English speaking immigrant populations. Think about how non-English speaking immigrants are treated in Southern California? Are they treated as equals?
This comment has been removed by the author.
Deleteoogle limited the length of my comment, so I will finish it here:
Delete_______________________________________
Part 2: There isn't a clean break between the first and second experiment. I had trouble finding where one ended and the other began.
I don't see much in terms of your description of this second experiment. Usually the most interesting part of this experiment is the response of the partner. Some have actually gotten angry and stormed out. It would have offered more information for both you and your reader if this had been expanded.
I don't disagree with your conclusions regarding the information we receive from body language, but you are only considering the situation where body language matches and supports the information you receive from spoken language. What does it tell you when the body language doesn't match the spoken language? Humans tend to use body language as a type of lie detector. If spoken words don't match with the body language, we are more inclined to believe the body language and doubt the words. Think about how being able to detect liars might help an individual's ability to survive and reproduce (which applies to the next section).
The next section is asking you to pull in what you have learned on human evolution and assess the evolutionary (adaptive) benefits of being able to read body language effectively. I don't see where you address this. How can reading body language help with survival, competing for resources, finding a mate and reproductive success? And what type of benefits do you get by being able to detect liars?
Can you identify individuals who have difficulty reading body language? I don't see a response to this question. Like all human traits, there is normal variation in expression, and the ability to read body language is no different. But beyond that, there are groups of people who have great difficulty or an outright inability to read body language due to physical or mental disability, such as those who are in the autism spectrum or those who are blind (though they can read vocal intonation).
Your final example is all situations where the body language is giving accurate information. It's telling the truth. You can choose to not respond but any time body language gives you accurate information, it is not to your benefit to ignore it. But is there any situation you can think of where body language might actually mislead you (and should therefore be avoided), not because the person is lying but because you don't know how to read the body language? Do all cultures use the same system of body language? They all use different systems of spoken/written language, so why would we assume their body language isn't different? If you travel to another country, can you trust the information you get from their body language?
Delete
Hi Alma! I full agree with your last paragraph that understanding the cues body language gives us can help us understand how the individual is feeling in that exact moment. They might say one thing but the tone in their voice and body language say another. It is so important in non verbal conversations as you can indicate how exactly the "conversation" is going! Thank you for your post, it was great to read.
ReplyDeleteHello Alma,
ReplyDeleteI found you post to be very detailed and filled with a lot of great information. To start, I noticed we both describe part 1 of this experiment as charades. Which I completely felt like it was. I like that you applied details on different cultures and what different gestures or silence may mean. I also liked the point you presented with anxiety and how body language will become fidgety and that is a sign of anxiety.